A book review at The New Republic has an interesting take on a significant question.
This book is depressing because it is so persuasive. There is a school of thought in America which argues that the government must be the main force that provides help to the black community. This shibboleth is predicated upon another one: that such government efforts will make a serious difference in disparities between blacks and whites. Amy Wax not only argues that such efforts have failed, she also suggests that such efforts cannot bring equality, and therefore must be abandoned. Wax identifies the illusion that mars American thinking on this subject as the myth of reverse causationâ€”that if racism was the cause of a problem, then eliminating racism will solve it. If only this were true. But it isnâ€™t true: racism can set in motion cultural patterns that take on a life of their own.
Wax appeals to a parable in which a pedestrian is run over by a truck and must learn to walk again. The truck driver pays the pedestrianâ€™s medical bills, but the only way the pedestrian will walk again is through his own efforts. The pedestrian may insist that the driver do more, that justice has not occurred until the driver has himself made the pedestrian learn to walk again. But the sad fact is that justice, under this analysis, is impossible. The legal theory about remedies, Wax points out, grapples with this inconvenienceâ€”and the history of the descendants of African slaves, no matter how horrific, cannot upend its implacable logic. As she puts it, â€œThat blacks did not, in an important sense, cause their current predicament does not preclude charging them with alleviating it if nothing else will work.â€
Wax is well aware that past discrimination created black-white disparities in education, wealth, and employment.
The book being reviewed is not a diatribe against blacks. It is a discussion of the implications of culture as more significant than the implications of race.
This is something I have seen touched on before, particularly in Ruby Payne’s work, discussed here, for example.
I found the book review because I read Right on the Left Coast regularly.